Searching for Bexley OH real estate can be both exciting and overwhelming, especially if you’re not familiar with this upscale Columbus suburb. Known for its historic homes, excellent schools, and tree-lined streets, Bexley is one of the most desirable places to live in central Ohio. Whether you’re a first-time buyer, relocating professional, or real estate investor, understanding the local market is essential for making a confident purchase.

Located just minutes east of downtown Columbus, Bexley offers a unique mix of suburban charm and urban convenience. The city is known for its architectural beauty, community spirit, and access to cultural and educational amenities, making it especially attractive to families and professionals.

In this article, we’ll explore every aspect of the Bexley OH real estate market — from home prices and housing styles to top neighborhoods, investment opportunities, and practical tips for buyers.

Why Bexley, Ohio Is a Top Real Estate Market

Historic and Prestigious

Bexley is home to some of the most beautiful historic homes in Ohio. The city’s charm is deeply rooted in its early 20th-century architecture, with colonial, Tudor, and craftsman-style homes lining the streets.

Central Location

Just 10 minutes from downtown Columbus and within close proximity to John Glenn Columbus International Airport, Bexley is ideal for commuters and frequent travelers alike.

Excellent Schools

The Bexley City School District is one of the top-rated public school systems in Ohio, making the area highly attractive to families with children.

Strong Community Culture

From summer festivals to neighborhood gatherings, Bexley offers a strong sense of community and civic pride.

Bexley OH Real Estate Market Overview

Current Home Prices

Bexley is considered a higher-end market within the Columbus metro area. Home prices reflect the area’s desirability and historical appeal.

• Median Home Price: ~$550,000 (subject to fluctuation)
• Price Range: ~$350,000 to $2 million+
• Average Days on Market: 20–40 days
• Price per Square Foot: Varies widely depending on property size and condition, generally around $250–$400

Market Trends

• Low Inventory: Bexley often has fewer homes for sale compared to neighboring areas, which can lead to competitive bidding.
• High Demand: Families and professionals continue to move into Bexley for its school district and amenities.
• Appreciation Rates: Real estate in Bexley has consistently appreciated over the last decade, making it a strong investment area.

Popular Neighborhoods in Bexley, OH

1. Central Bexley

Home to the city’s most prestigious homes, including large historic estates with mature landscaping and architectural detail. It’s highly walkable and close to schools, parks, and shopping.

2. North Bexley

Known for its grand homes and large lots, North Bexley appeals to those seeking privacy and luxury while still being near downtown Columbus.

3. South Bexley

More affordable than Central and North Bexley, South Bexley features charming bungalows and smaller homes. It’s popular with young families and first-time buyers.

Types of Homes in Bexley

Single-Family Homes

The dominant home type in Bexley, ranging from cozy two-bedroom cottages to sprawling luxury estates. Many homes have been carefully restored and preserved.

Historic Properties

Bexley is known for its early 20th-century homes, many of which have been updated with modern amenities while maintaining their original charm.

Newer Construction

While rare, some newer homes and renovated properties do exist, particularly in South Bexley or where older homes have been replaced or remodeled.

Condos and Townhomes

Less common but available, particularly on the edges of Bexley. These are ideal for downsizers or investors seeking rental income.

What to Consider When Buying in Bexley

School District Influence

Homes within the Bexley City School District typically sell at a premium. Be sure to confirm district boundaries before purchasing.

Property Taxes

Due to its location and services, Bexley’s property taxes are higher than some surrounding areas. This should be factored into your long-term costs.

Age of Homes

Many Bexley homes are older and may require updates or maintenance. Always get a thorough inspection, especially for roof, HVAC, and foundation issues.

Competition

Due to high demand and limited supply, buyers should be prepared to act quickly and possibly compete in bidding wars, especially for homes in Central Bexley.

Bexley Real Estate Investment Potential

Steady Appreciation

The consistent demand for homes in Bexley has led to reliable appreciation, making it a solid choice for long-term investors.

Rental Market

Bexley’s proximity to downtown Columbus and nearby universities like Capital University creates a steady rental demand for well-maintained homes.

Fix-and-Flip Opportunities

While most of Bexley is well-developed, there are occasional opportunities to purchase outdated homes and renovate for profit, particularly in South Bexley.

FAQs About Bexley OH Real Estate

Is Bexley a good place to live?

Yes, Bexley is known for its top-rated schools, safe neighborhoods, and strong community culture. It’s consistently ranked as one of the best places to live in Ohio.

How competitive is the real estate market in Bexley?

The market is competitive, especially for homes in prime neighborhoods. Well-priced homes can sell in just days with multiple offers.

Are there affordable homes in Bexley?

While the market leans toward high-end properties, South Bexley and some townhome developments offer relatively affordable options.

What makes Bexley different from nearby suburbs?

Bexley stands out for its historic architecture, highly rated public schools, and its proximity to downtown Columbus. It offers a more urban feel compared to other suburbs.

Tips for Buyers in Bexley, Ohio

1. Get Pre-Approved Early

Sellers often favor buyers who are already pre-approved for a mortgage. This shows seriousness and gives you a better shot in multiple-offer situations.

2. Hire a Local Real Estate Agent

Bexley has a unique real estate landscape. A knowledgeable local agent can help you navigate listings, negotiate prices, and understand neighborhood dynamics.

3. Be Flexible with Timing

Homes move quickly, so flexibility and preparedness are key. Monitor listings daily and be ready to view homes the same day they’re listed.

4. Consider Long-Term Value

While Bexley homes may come at a premium, their long-term value and appreciation potential often justify the initial cost.

Conclusion

Bexley OH real estate offers more than just beautiful homes — it provides access to a thriving, educated community with top-notch schools, charming architecture, and unmatched convenience. Whether you’re looking for a historic estate in Central Bexley or a cozy starter home in the south, this city offers a range of options to fit different lifestyles and budgets.

With demand high and inventory often low, it’s crucial to be informed, prepared, and proactive when entering the Bexley real estate market. From elegant streetscapes to strong investment returns, Bexley is a place where homeowners don’t just buy property — they invest in a way of life.

Thinking about moving to Bexley? Reach out to a local real estate expert or explore nearby listings to get started on your journey today.